incident.io vs PagerDuty

We're built from the ground up for teams who want more than just a wake-up call. We handle everything from alerts to resolution in one sleek, intuitive platform.

Incidents don't stop when you are paged, neither do we

From alert to resolution, give your team everything they need to respond quickly, reduce downtime, and keep customers in the loop.

The PagerDuty way

Trusted for alerting, but stops short—leaving teams to manage chaos across disconnected tools.

The incident.io way

Run the entire incident in one place, with context, comms, and control from start to finish.


What makes PagerDuty hard to love?

PagerDuty pioneered on-call and we have a lot to thank them for… Yet these days a lot of customers are fed up with clunky setups, hidden costs, and the sense that their product just isn't evolving.

Poor experience for non-engineers

Easy for everyone to use, not just engineers.

Complex setup that takes weeks

Fast, intuitive setup that works out of the box.

Rigid alert rules and team structures

Flexible alert rules and team structures.

Hidden costs for basic features

Transparent pricing for all features.

UI that hasn't changed in years

Modern, evolving UI

The PagerDuty Rescue Program

The single biggest reason teams stay on PagerDuty isn’t the product, it’s the pain of leaving. We’ve removed every barrier.
See how switching works

Migration, handled

We scope your migration before you commit, then plan and execute it. Purpose-built tooling and white-glove migration from the team that's moved Trainline, Zendesk, DocuSign, and Intercom.

Contract buyout

Stuck mid-contract? We cover the overlap so you’re not paying two vendors at once. Up to 12 months free on a multi-year deal.

99.99% uptime, in writing*

We commit to 99.99% uptime in our SLA. PagerDuty's SLA is 99.9%. That gap matters at 3am.

* 99.99% SLA available on Enterprise plans. All plans include 99.9% uptime SLA.

Hundreds of teams have already made the switch

We migrated 1,200 users, 150 teams, and 5,000 monitors to incident.io with a core team of two and saw zero major issues. Our engineers called it one of the smoothest migrations at Zendesk. We've saved hundreds of hours of operational overhead and seen a significant reduction in our costs for observability, monitoring, and alerting. Frankly, it's been one of the best tooling decisions we've made.

Tom Monaghan

VP, Engineering Productivity & Product Reliability

The transition was incredibly smooth. Our engineers immediately preferred incident.io over PagerDuty, and adoption across the broader company quickly followed.

Mark Gorman

Technical Program Manager

I wouldn’t be too intimidated by the migration. incident.io’s team will support you throughout. You don’t have to feel like you’re taking it on single-handedly. Ground yourself in what the outcome could be: not just cost savings, but quality of life for your on-call engineers, better learnings from these stressful situations, and ultimately a more reliable product for your customers.

Dylan Bochman

Incident Commander

Almost immediately, everything worked out of the box. It was very intuitive. The licensing was really straightforward. And when we compared the costs, it was just a no-brainer for us. We got a whole incident management platform with the paging piece already built in.

Leigh Darlow

Head of Platform Engineering

Move across as soon as you can. Convince your senior leaders it's the right thing to do, get your buy-in, and then get stuck in. You learn a lot, you tidy up a lot of tech debt, and you come out the other side in a much better place.

Dan Cook

Reliability & Operations Manager


How migration actually works

No ambiguity, no surprises. Here's exactly what happens when you start.

  1. 01

    We scan your PagerDuty environment

    You share a read-only API key. Our analyzer audits everything - schedules, escalation policies, integrations, Event Orchestration rules, automation actions, and the hidden dependencies your team doesn't even know are there.

  2. 02

    You get a tailored migration plan

    From the scan, we generate a custom migration guide for you with a complexity score, timeline estimate, and phased plan covering six streams: account setup, alert connections, routing, dependencies, onboarding prep, and user cutover.

  3. 03

    Our team migrates you

    Our team works hand-in-hand with yours through three phases: Test (parallel running, no risk), Trial (live traffic, safety nets on), Go-Live (PagerDuty off).


Built for everyone in the room

Configure your alerting tool once, and route alerts with the power of Catalog. Route based on features, teams, systems, or services, making sure engineers only get paged when they need to be.

Engineers
Support and Sales
Leaders
Security and Privacy

Start with on-call, scale when you’re ready

Our product is built to be flexible. While we believe that our end-to-end incident response is best-in-class, but we understand that not all teams are ready to make the full switch.

Get a demo
  • On-call

    Modern on-call and alert management system built for fast moving engineering teams

  • On-call
    Incident Response
    AI SRE
    Status pages
    Insights

    End-to-end incident management platform

    From alert to resolution, give your team everything they need to respond quickly, reduce downtime, and keep customers in the loop.

How does incident.io compare with PagerDuty?

PagerDuty
incident.io

Alerting

Deep ecosystem of integrations

Native support for systems like Datadog, Grafana, Alertmanager, Honeycomb, Cronitor, etc.


Alert grouping and filtering

Filter inbound alerts, and group based on content and time window.

(requires AIOps add-on)


Generic alert support

For non-natively supported alerting integrations, connect via HTTP, email, etc.


Unified incident management

Selectively ungroup alerts during an incident, in the event that they've been grouped incorrectly.


Modern on-call experience

Enrich alerts with context from external systems, like a service catalog, HRIS system, or CRM.


Scheduling

Scheduling

Create on-call schedules, including basic/single team, through more complex follow-the-sun


Advanced Scheduling

Support for advanced, multi-layer schedules to support dual-on-call, shadow rotations, etc.

(requires multiple separate schedules, no guarantees two people paged)


Overrides

Support for individuals to override the configured schedule for a period of time, for example to cover someone on vacation


Requesting cover

The ability for on-callers to request cover for an on-call shift and have the system find someone to take it and then configure the override


Escalation paths (policies)

Support for schedules and individuals to be linked together with rules for escalating, i.e. notify the first line, but if they don't acknowledge, escalate to L2


Synchronize schedules with calendar

Synchronize an on-call schedule with an external calendar, like Google


Notifications

Configure personal notification preferences

Configure the order and timing of all notifications


Synchronize schedules with Slack user groups

Synchronize active on-callers to a Slack user group


Support for multiple notification channels

Phone, SMS, Email, Push notifications and Slack


Other

Native Android and iOS App

Native mobile applications, approved by Google and Apple, and downloadable through the respective app stores


On-call compensation calculator

Calculate how much individuals are owed for on-call, subject to custom rules



Momentum leaders

Don't trust us? See how we stack up in the market

Read G2 reviews

Escape the pager duty

You've wanted out for a while. Now there's nothing stopping you.